Seton Hall and Creighton haven’t any selection. They each have to win the Big East Tournament in the event that they’re going to earn a ticket to the Big Dance.
The Pirates have the higher total report at 20-11, however just one sport separated these two groups within the last Big East standings, and they break up the head-to-head matchup, with each video games determined by one possession.
In different phrases, it’s no marvel that the chances for Thursday’s tilt are fairly tight. Seton Hall is a 3.5-point favourite at FanDuel Sportsbook.
Seton Hall vs. Creighton odds, prediction
Madison Square Garden is an iconic boxing venue, so we’ll borrow an adage from the candy science for this handicapping journey: Styles make fights.
No. 4 Seton Hall and No. 5 Creighton had comparable Big East seasons and performed two tight video games, however they may hardly be extra totally different stylistically.
The Blue Jays like to chuck it from downtown. They took probably the most 3-pointers of any staff within the Big East this season, and they didn’t really feel a necessity to regulate regardless of a mediocre conversion charge (one hundred and twenty fifth).
Betting on College Basketball?

Seton Hall, alternatively, not often heaves it from past the arc. There are 365 Division I basketball packages, and solely three of them shot fewer 3-pointers per sport than the Pirates in 2025-26.
Given their aversion to trying 3-pointers, it’s no marvel that Seton Hall performs at a snail’s tempo. The Pirates rank 305th in KenPom’s adjusted tempo metric, whereas Creighton is far nearer to common. The Blue Jays aren’t seeking to rise up and down the ground, however it might look that manner in comparison with Seton Hall.
This story of the tape is filled with contradictions, however probably the most notable edge is on protection. Seton Hall isn’t simply one of many best defensive sides within the Big East, however they grade out as one of many best items in your entire nation. KenPom has the Pirates because the Thirteenth-best protection in Division I, and Bart Torvik has them only a shade decrease at No. 16.
Seton Hall’s offense leaves loads to be desired, however the Pirates shall be going up in opposition to a leaky protection, which ought to assist them hold this sport on their phrases. The final thing Seton Hall needs is to be chasing Creighton, however its stalwart protection ought to forestall that from occurring.
We’ll lay the factors with the Pirates on Thursday.
The Play: Seton Hall -3.5 (-102, FanDuel)
Why Trust New York Post Betting
Michael Leboff is a long-suffering Islanders fan, however a long-profiting sports activities bettor with 10 years of expertise within the playing trade. He loves utilizing sport principle to assist punters win bracket swimming pools, discover lengthy pictures, and discover ways to beat the market in mainstream and area of interest sports activities.