April 23, 2026, 12:01 p.m. ET
They cannot all be winners, proper?
Before we get began, let’s get one thing out of the way in which: Detroit Lions normal supervisor Brad Holmes has executed a comparatively distinctive job drafting since he took the position in 2021. Identifying Holmes’ five-worst draft picks – a lot much less 5 unhealthy draft picks in any respect – was a problem.
But not all draft picks work out. That’s why this listing is not going to embrace the worst gamers who’ve been drafted by Holmes, however the worst picks relative to their draft worth.
[ NFL mock draft predictions 4.0: Every pick in Round 1 ]
Let’s have a look:
No. 5: Tyleik Williams, DT (2025 first spherical, 28 general)
Choosing Tyleik Williams as one among Holmes’ 5 worst draft picks is admittedly not completely truthful. He simply completed his rookie season, and he might be in contrast with the likes of Penei Sewell, Aidan Hutchinson, Jahmyr Gibbs and Jameson Williams. All of these gamers have been drafted within the high 12, whereas Williams got here in at No. 28 general.
Here’s the factor, although – Williams was, charitably, the third-most impactful participant from Detroit’s 2025 draft class, behind second-round choose Tate Ratledge and third-round choose Isaac TeSlaa. That could be OK if Williams performed as much as his first-round billing, however he solely began 10 video games final 12 months, and never as a result of he was harm for the opposite seven.
There’s nonetheless loads of time for him to develop into his position, however the Lions are hoping he takes a king-sized step in 2025 to cement a starring position on the defensive inside.
No. 4: Terrion Arnold, CB (2024 first spherical, twenty fourth general)
Terrion Arnold was the group’s most penalized player and arguably its worst common defensive again in his rookie season in 2024. And to his credit score, he performed significantly better when wholesome in 2025 and was sorely missed in a depleted secondary for the previous few video games of the season.
But even taking his damage points into consideration, Arnold hasn’t lived as much as his first-round billing. And although we do not know what the fallout from his alleged ties to a Florida kidnapping might be, the best-case situation nonetheless would not look flattering. While the jury continues to be out on Williams, Arnold is fairly clearly Holmes’ worst-performing first-round choice to this point.
No. 3: Brodric Martin (2023 third spherical, 96th general)
Of the 18 gamers Holmes has chosen within the first three rounds of the draft, solely 4 are now not with the Lions – quarterback Hendon Hooker (extra on him in a second), defensive finish Josh Paschal (accidents), defensive again Ifeatu Melifonwu (began eight video games for Miami in 2025) and defensive sort out Brodric Martin. And of these 4, Martin stands out in a foul method.
Martin performed in solely 5 video games for the Lions in his two seasons in Detroit from 2023-24, beginning solely as soon as and recording 4 tackles. His final likelihood to make the group got here in the course of the 2025 preseason, however Martin did not present a lot on the sector before the Lions cut him.
Holmes has hit on third-round picks earlier than, most notably with defensive sort out Alim McNeil in 2021 and security Kerby Joseph in 2022. But Martin was unquestionably a miss.
No. 2: Gio Manu, OL (2024 fourth spherical, 126th general)
There’s hardly such a factor as a foul fourth-round choice, and the 6-7, 350-pound offensive sort out was at the least an attention-grabbing choose in 2024. But time is operating out on the Giovanni Manu experiment.
The Lions and Manu agreed to deal with 2024 because the 24-year-old rookie’s “redshirt year,” as Manu nonetheless had a lot to be taught concerning the sport. And when Manu received his first snaps in 2025 whereas changing an injured Taylor Decker, he typically appeared overwhelmed an incapable of dealing with an vital place.
It says sufficient that the Lions have a right away and pressing want for a beginning sort out, however no indicators point out that the group is prepared at hand the reigns to Manu. His ceiling could also be as a backup, and provided that the Lions are prepared to proceed with this venture.
No. 1: Hendon Hooker, QB (2023 third spherical, 68th general)
There isn’t any consensus opinion with regards to backup quarterback technique within the NFL, however there are a pair go-to formulation, particularly for groups with already-established beginning quarterbacks. There’s the costly veteran backup, a superb choice for a group that wants instant legitimacy ought to the starter miss time. Then there’s the uncooked however toolsy prospect that may want a couple of years of bench time to arrange for a beginning position.
The hassle with Hooker is that he doesn’t match both profile. Hooker, coming off a torn ACL in school, by no means had sufficient buzz to warrant an early-round prognostication when he was drafted. Instead, Hooker sat on the roster with out a lot of a path to a beginning position and with out sufficient expertise to warrant belief as a backup.
So it wasn’t a shock that the Lions cut Hooker after a disappointing 2025 preseason, neither is it a shock that three different groups have given him an opportunity since. But his solely taking part in time came to visit three video games in 2024, making him arguably the least impactful Brad Holmes choose relative to his draft place.
Need to make amends for the information throughout your lunch break? Sign up for our Sports Briefing newsletter to get every day summaries of Detroit sports activities!
You can attain Christian at cromo@freepress.com.
